If you are ever driving the Southern Tier on Interstate 86, between New York & Buffalo, you NEED to stop here for dinner. I’m talking like you need oxygen to live! I would have never thought to find one of the best restaurants anywhere in small town Pennsylvania.
I’ve eaten there about 20 times and without fail the food was amazing. The Ribeye steak is the BEST I’ve ever had and I grew up in the West where beef grows on trees, The beet & Spinach salad is amazing. The pork chops, filet, Margherita Pizza and lemon cake for dessert.
The atmosphere and congenial nature of the staff top it all off. It’s not cheap, but I promise it is worth every penny. you’ll stop on the way back too! 3/23/15
This place never ceases to amaze me! The shrimp cocktail is comprised of some of the biggest shrimp I’ve ever seen. And the Ribeye? Still the best I’ve ever had anywhere. They were having a NY Strip with a peppercorn reduction, but I wanted the reduction with the Ribeye. The chef accommodated me. Dessert was Tres Leches with a berry sauce on top! Deliciosso! The place is a gastronomical oasis in the dining desert of rural upstate New York. 8/16/16
What was once an out-dated, run down hotel is now a jewel in the center of town, Beautiful rooms for overnight guests, fantastic fare in a charming restaurant, cozy surroundings in the popular bar. Well run, tastefully decorated, outdoor fun on Fridays in warm weather and patio dining is available. The menu is creative and the service is superb. A wonderful addition to downtown Sayre. 8/16/2016
“Great Solo Dinner at The Bar”
A lovely, quaint restaurant, but I was traveling alone so I chose the bar. For a Monday night, there were many tables occupied. When I inquired at the hotel that I was staying at where to dine, they recommended this establishment, without a doubt. Not very hungry this particular evening so I did not take the time to enjoy a soup or salad. I did however, enjoy the NY Strip prepared medium as requested it came with mashed sweet potatoes and very nicely prepared brussel sprouts (and I am not a brussel sprout fan). Outstanding service from the waitress that met me at the door and throughout my dinner. Sorry I do not remember her name, but she was truly outstanding. I do recommend this establishment and will definitely return when I am in the area again. 12/13/16